The uninformed public, led by the misinformed 'experts'
posted 7-29-2010 2:51 p.m. Central

 
Sometimes, disinformation is spread by perfectly well-meaning people who are less informed than they think they are. And they don’t even realize they’re doing it. Trouble is, if their credentials look good at first glance, the rest of us may not realize it, either. This is one of the frustrations of covering health care reform.

Case in point: a New York cardiologist volunteers to provide aid for several months in Haiti after the earthquake. He’s part of a team helping to reinstate cardiac care at a city hospital in Port-au-Prince. A noble deed, well and good. While he’s there, he notices that the “sudden availability in Haiti of free high-quality care from foreign doctors put enormous competitive pressure on the private local doctors, who had already been working under difficult conditions.” This influx of foreign aid causes local clinics to lose business. The cardiologist wonders “if the same would happen to private medical services back in the United States were our government to suddenly provide high-quality, low-cost health care.” So he writes an op-ed piece for the New York Times with suggestions for our health care reform efforts, based on his experience in Haiti.

I begin to see where this guy's argument is going and shake my head, but I keep reading, giving him the benefit of the doubt for the moment. Yet already the misunderstandings are piling up.