Fixing health care reform: too many missing pieces now, but we can build on parts that work
posted 5-12-2009 2:17 p.m.

 
There are those who liken tinkering around the edges of health care reform (which is all Congress and the president have attempted, so far) to fixing a leaky faucet or unclogging a drain in New Orleans while Hurricane Katrina approaches: there’s a much bigger picture that needs to be addressed. I agree with that last part, but to me the health care system is more of a Rube-Goldberg machine or a potential This Old House project: it began long ago with a very small core and was slowly cobbled together over time to do more and more but performs in a costly, roundabout, less than effective way — yet our attempts to improve it have only resulted in more things cobbled on, without rethinking the entire design.

With the rising clamor for a public health insurance plan as an alternative mechanism for covering everyone, it’s time to think about whether or not we have the pieces of the delivery system in place to make a public health plan effective. I don’t think we do. However, we do have pieces that are useful now and would be good to incorporate into any reformed delivery system. We have to retain those parts while we figure out what our care system needs to look like, which will determine what our reform plan must look like.